Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jennifer Lahl MA, BSN, RN's avatar

Wow! Back to School Binders. These companies can't go out of business soon enough.

Expand full comment
Johanna's avatar

Helena, thanks for this! I think you’re right: a lot of adult defenders, advocates and nurturers of trans youth need to take a good look in the mirror.

I’m sure most are well-meaning and believe they are simply “supporting” a teen’s own deep-seated, unquenchable desire to be their authentic self. But how do they know they aren’t actually leading that teen further down a trans path than they would have gone by themselves? Especially when they step in to help the kid squelch any self-doubt, consistently take their side against their parents (without meeting said parents), and express admiration for their incredible bravery in “coming out” as trans.

A caring adult mentor outside the family (whether a teacher, coach, therapist or a friend’s Really Cool Mom) can have a huge impact in adolescence—even when relationships with your own parents are close. When they’re not, the influence can be even greater. It can be intoxicating for the mentor as well. Who has never dreamed of being a hero? A “rescue fantasy” of saving a kid trapped in a terrible home that is crushing their spirit could certainly scratch that itch, especially if the trans cause is popular in your community. Would like to know how younger detransitioners feel, looking back, about the role of “highly affirming” adults in their lives when they identified as trans.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts